Profile Pricing Drives NDR Drop

This drop shows that profile based pricing became a cost line customers could trim immediately, which turned retention from a product quality story into a data hygiene story. These platforms charge in part on how many user records sit in the system, so when finance teams cut spend, marketers and ops teams deleted dormant contacts, merged duplicates, and stepped down plans. That reduced expansion revenue even when the core workflow stayed embedded.

• In Customer.io, a billable profile is a person or object profile active in the account during the month. That means cleanup work directly lowers the bill. The effect is mechanical, not necessarily a sign that customers are replacing the product or sending fewer important messages.
  4 customer 5 customer
• Customer.io, Klaviyo, and Braze all saw retention normalize toward the low 110s after the 2021 peak. Braze reported dollar based net retention falling from 126% to 118% by October 2023, while Klaviyo reported 119% in Q3 2023 and later retention around the low 110s. The pattern was category wide.
  1 sacra 3 sacra 6 braze 7 klaviyo
• This also explains why Customer.io moved into Data Pipelines and broader platform products. If the messaging seat or profile base gets right sized, the best way to regain expansion is to sell adjacent tools that help ingest data, route it, and make the messaging product easier to keep in place.
  2 sacra 8 sacra

The next leg of growth comes from shifting pricing away from just stored profiles and toward a broader system of record for customer engagement. As these vendors add CDP, SMS, in app, and AI workflow products, expansion should come less from bloated contact counts and more from owning more of the customer data and messaging stack.