Selling transformation not content
Sid Yadav, co-founder & CEO of Circle, on the 3 types of community businesses
This reveals that Circle is pricing against outcomes, not content hosting. The buyers willing to pay up are not purchasing a place to upload lessons, they are buying software to run a business that changes a member's job, income, health, or network. That is why Circle keeps expanding from forums into courses, events, email, payments, websites, and AI, because higher priced communities need one system to deliver an end to end experience.
-
The clearest pattern is that the strongest community businesses sell a concrete before and after. Circle groups them into professional networks, learning academies, and life clubs, all categories where members pay for access to peers, structure, accountability, and live help, not just information.
-
This also explains expansion revenue. As a community proves it can drive member outcomes, operators add email, websites, AI agents, events, and higher tiers instead of stitching together separate tools. The more serious the business becomes, the more valuable an integrated stack becomes.
-
The contrast with adjacent creator platforms is simple. Kajabi is built around selling courses and digital products, while Patreon is built around recurring fan support. Circle is pushing toward businesses where the community itself is the product, which supports higher prices and deeper retention.
Going forward, the creator economy keeps moving away from selling access to files and toward selling progress. That favors platforms that can help an operator onboard members, host live sessions, organize peer interaction, answer routine questions, and capture payments in one place. The winners are likely to look less like media tools and more like operating systems for paid transformation businesses.