Beehiiv Turns Newsletters Into Profit Engines
Diving deeper into
Beehiiv
Beehiiv has positioned itself as a solution for email newsletter writers who want to own their audience and scale their following without paying a cut of all their revenues to a platform like Substack.
Analyzed 4 sources
Reviewing context
Beehiiv is winning by turning newsletter software into a cheaper profit engine, not just a writing tool. A creator who outgrows hobby publishing can keep subscriber revenue instead of handing over 10% forever, then add Beehiiv’s ad network and Boosts to make money from free readers too. That makes Beehiiv feel closer to creator SaaS like Kit than to Substack’s media network model.
-
The money flow is different. Beehiiv mainly charges software fees, and by mid 2025 about $10M of its $30M annualized revenue came from ads and Boosts. In Boosts, one newsletter pays for a new subscriber, another newsletter displays the promo, and Beehiiv keeps 20% of that transaction.
-
Substack’s model gets more expensive as a writer succeeds. By July 2025 it was taking 10% on roughly $450M of GMV across 5M paid subscriptions, which creates a strong reason for larger writers to consider lower take rate tools, even if moving is operationally painful once years of posts and subscriber payments are embedded on platform.
-
The competitive gap is now less about writing and publishing, and more about what kind of business a creator is building. Beehiiv and Kit focus on list growth, ads, and software control. Substack has increasingly leaned into feed, discovery, chat, and video, which helps audience acquisition but also makes the platform itself more central.
The market is moving toward hybrid newsletter platforms where software revenue and creator monetization tools sit side by side. Beehiiv’s next step is to keep pulling higher earning writers off revenue share platforms, then deepen lock in with ad demand, cross promotion, and other tools that make an owned email list more valuable over time.