SecondMarket as NPM Loss Leader
Hari Raghavan, ex-COO of Forge, on late-stage investing and facilitating secondary sales
Calling SecondMarket a loss leader for NPM means the secondary product matters less as a standalone profit center than as an early relationship wedge into future Nasdaq listings. The tool helps private companies run tightly controlled tender offers, but those offers happen occasionally, not continuously. That makes it useful for winning issuer trust and staying close to companies before IPO, even if the bigger economic prize sits later in listings and related capital markets services.
-
SecondMarket shifted from open marketplace trading into issuer controlled liquidity programs, and Nasdaq later used that technology for tender offers. That move traded away always on market activity for a workflow that private company CFOs and legal teams were more willing to approve.
-
NPM handled about $4.8B of transaction volume across 87 secondary programs in 2019, which shows real scale, but tender offers are still episodic. They are company run events used for employee liquidity, cap table cleanup, or IPO price discovery, not a daily market for shares.
-
That positioning contrasts with Forge, EquityZen, and broker led venues that chase more frequent bilateral trades between buyers and sellers. NPM is closer to enterprise software for issuers, while brokered and marketplace models are built around transaction flow and commissions.
The direction of travel is toward platforms splitting into distinct roles, issuer systems on one side, and trading and brokerage networks on the other. If private companies keep staying private longer, the winners will be the firms that either own the issuer relationship early or capture the recurring flow of buyers and sellers around that issuer over time.